1940sdeancas:

Okay but what about an episode with a siren-like creature with the ability to take on the visage of someone’s true love?

Like Sam and Dean will be in a motel working the case trying to figure out its next move. Cas will have gone off for a beer run (and maybe to sneak in a petting session at a nearby pet store). And then later Cas will return to the motel empty-handed and Dean will be like, “Dude. Again? You seriously forgot the-”

But then he stops when he glances back at Sam, who looks petrified as fuck all of a sudden. “What the hell is wrong with you?”

When Sam finally gets his mouth working, he just says, “Jess?”